Opinion · AI
The AI scribe is the easy part
By Element 45 · 9 September 2026

Drafting the note was never the hard problem. What a clinic does with the time, and with the transcript, is.
AI scribes are the first piece of artificial intelligence most clinicians have used in a consult. They listen, transcribe and hand back a draft note. They have spread quickly because the problem they solve is obvious: clinicians spend a large part of the day typing, and nobody chose medicine for the typing.
We think the enthusiasm is justified. We also think the scribe is the least interesting thing about what is happening. The note is the easy part. The harder questions are what happens to the time, who checks the draft, and who ends up owning a recording of everything said in the room.
A note is not the job
Documentation is a by-product of care. A tool that makes the by-product cheaper can easily produce more of it: longer notes, more complete notes, notes nobody reads. The measure of a scribe should be whether the next clinician finds what they need faster, and whether the person in front of the clinician got more attention. Neither shows up in a word count.
A scribe that saves ten minutes a session has done nothing for the patient until someone decides what those ten minutes are for.
Practices adopting a scribe should decide in advance where the saved time goes. Longer consultations, more consultations and an earlier finish are all defensible answers. Leaving it undecided means the time disappears into the schedule and the clinician feels no different in six months.
Someone still has to read it
A draft that is nearly always right invites the reader to stop checking. That is a known pattern with automation, and a clinical note is a poor place for it. An invented medication, a missed negation or a symptom attributed to the wrong person in the room can sit in a record for years.
The regulator has been clear on where responsibility sits. Ahpra’s 2024 guidance on AI in healthcare leaves the practitioner accountable for the accuracy of the record, whatever produced the first draft. Vendors that describe their product as taking documentation off the clinician’s hands are selling something the rules do not allow. The honest pitch is that the clinician edits a draft where they used to write one.

The transcript is the asset
A scribe produces two things: the note, and a recording or transcript of the whole conversation. The second is far more valuable than the first. It contains everything the patient said, including what never made it into the record.
That raises questions most practices have not asked. Is the audio kept, and for how long? Is it used to train the vendor’s models? Is it stored in Australia? Can the patient ask for it? Consent that amounts to a sign on the wall does not cover any of this. Patients should be asked each time, in plain words, and a refusal should cost them nothing.
What we would do
Ask for consent at every consultation and record that it was given. Delete the audio once the note is signed. Choose a product that lets the practice take its data out. Decide where the saved time goes before the trial starts, and measure it afterwards.
None of that is technically hard. It is the part that decides whether scribes make care better or only make notes longer.